PTA Lawyer Misleads Court on X Ban Status in Pakistan

In recent months, the status of X, formerly known as Twitter, has been a topic of significant discussion in Pakistan. The platform has faced a ban that has lasted over seven months, leaving many users frustrated and seeking clarity on the situation. The Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) has been at the center of this controversy, and a recent court hearing has only added to the confusion surrounding the ban.

During a hearing at the Sindh High Court on September 12, Ahsan Imam Rizvi, a lawyer representing the PTA, made a surprising claim. He stated that a government notification, which had instructed the PTA to block X back on February 17, had been withdrawn. This assertion led many in the courtroom and on social media to believe that the ban on X had been lifted, allowing users to access the platform once again.

However, the reality is quite different. On the same day that these claims were made, the PTA issued a press release clarifying that X was still "not accessible" in Pakistan. Malahat Obaid, the spokesperson for the PTA, confirmed this information, leaving many to wonder why the lawyer had made such a misleading statement in court.

Geo Fact Check, an independent fact-checking organization, attempted to access X and found that it remains blocked, with access only possible through a VPN. This further solidifies the fact that the ban is still in place, despite the lawyer's claims. When approached for clarification, Ahsan Imam Rizvi referred to his statement as a "mix-up" and a "misunderstanding," but did not provide any additional details to explain the confusion.

This incident highlights the ongoing challenges and miscommunications surrounding internet access in Pakistan. The ban on X has not only affected users but has also raised questions about the transparency and accountability of regulatory bodies like the PTA. As the digital landscape continues to evolve, it is crucial for authorities to communicate clearly and accurately with the public to avoid further misunderstandings.

While the claims made in court may have sparked hope among users eager to return to X, the reality remains that the platform is still blocked in Pakistan. This situation serves as a reminder of the importance of reliable information and the need for clear communication from those in positions of authority. As users navigate this digital landscape, staying informed and vigilant is essential.