Election Commission of Pakistan opposes retired judges in tribunals

The Election Act of 2017 has been at the center of attention recently due to the decision to restore the original provision of section 140. This provision allows retired judges of high courts to be considered for appointment as members of the election tribunal, specifically for hearing election petitions related to the National Assembly, the Senate, and Provincial Assemblies.

However, the Election Commission of Pakistan has taken a stand against this decision. They have declared that they will not accept the appointment of retired judges in the tribunals. This stance has led to a significant development where the party involved has announced that they will not proceed with cases scheduled to be heard by these retired judges.

The controversy stems from differing opinions on the suitability of retired judges to serve on election tribunals. Proponents argue that their experience and expertise make them valuable assets in ensuring fair and just hearings for election-related disputes. On the other hand, opponents raise concerns about potential biases and conflicts of interest that retired judges may bring to the tribunal.

The clash between the Election Commission of Pakistan and the proponents of appointing retired judges to election tribunals highlights the complexities and challenges in ensuring transparency and impartiality in the electoral process. As the debate continues, it is essential for all stakeholders to prioritize the integrity of the election system to uphold democracy and the rule of law.